Thursday October 29, 8:31 am Eastern Time
Company Press Release
Scientist Denounces
Elaborate Alien Signal Hoax
BOSTON--(BUSINESS-WIRE)--Oct. 29, 1998--On Monday, October 26, an
anonymous enthusiast of the search for extraterrestrial
intelligence (SETI) made a startling anonnouncement: we are not
alone in the universe. But within minutes of analysing the
alleged data, Professor Nathan Cohen of Boston University gave
the verdict: ``A hoax'', said Cohen. Not even a good one.``
The alleged discoverer claimed that he was a ham radio operator
piggybacking his SETI search off a British company's 30 foot
satellite dish. ``He talked the talk but didn't walk the walk'',
said Cohen. Calling himself 'anon', the hoaxster sent copies of
the data all over the internet, which Cohen quickly reviewed--and
was the first to reject.
``It stuck out like a sore thumb'', said Cohen. Unwilling to
elaborate on all of the signal's failings as an alien 'hit',
Cohen said ``my colleagues and I share the belief that we
shouldn't help the hoaxsters by telling them all that's wrong
with the fake.''
The major problem is that the signals were carbon copies on two
separate days of data, a probability that Cohen says would be
astronomically small as reality. But the main problem was the
signal lacked the channel bandwidth required of a SETI signal.
``The signal loses a tremendous amount of punch over cosmic
distances and you have to optimize the mode'', said Cohen. Cohen
showed in 1993 that distant SETI signals would be spread out in
frequency like teeth on a comb, in what is now called
'polychromatic SETI'. ``These 'sidebands' of the alleged signal
do nothing for helping detect it and are characteristic of an
Earth-based modulation method.'' While anon gave the position
close to that of a known star, Cohen asserts the star's position
information lacked a key detail which invalidates it as a real
one.
Cohen asserts that the 'signal' is a fabricated one or a snip of
a terrestrial satellite's signal being passed off as otherwise.
``A hacker gone wild. Too many 'Contact' reruns. Case closed'',
said Cohen.
This information is provided by SETINOW which sponsors
dissemination of important breakthroughs in SETI.